Skip to main content
📜 Bible & Scripture

Are there contradictions in the Bible?

📜 Bible & Scripture questions →
Question

Are there contradictions in the Bible?

Answer

This is one of the most common objections raised against the Bible, and it deserves an honest answer rather than either defensive dismissal or nervous concession.

First, a distinction: there are genuine difficulties and apparent contradictions in the Bible — passages that seem to conflict, numbers that seem inconsistent, accounts that seem to tell the same story differently. These are real, and pretending they do not exist is not helpful.

Second, there is an enormous difference between an apparent contradiction and an actual contradiction. A genuine logical contradiction requires two statements to be making the same claim about the same subject at the same time, and one to be true while the other is false. Most alleged biblical contradictions do not meet this standard.

Examples of common "contradictions" and their resolutions:

The Gospel accounts of the resurrection differ in details — how many angels were at the tomb, exactly who was present, in what order things happened. This is actually what you expect from multiple independent eyewitness accounts. If four accounts of the same event were identical in every detail, that would suggest copying, not independent testimony. Harmonisation of the accounts is reasonable.

Different numbers in parallel accounts (Kings vs. Chronicles) are often explained by copyist errors in transmission, different counting methods, or rounding conventions — none of which affects any doctrinal matter.

Passages that seem theologically contradictory — Paul saying we are saved by faith, James saying faith without works is dead — are not contradictory when read in context. Paul is addressing those who thought works could earn salvation; James is addressing those who claimed faith while showing no evidence of it. They are answering different questions.

Do genuine difficulties remain? Yes. There are passages I cannot fully harmonise to my own satisfaction. But the existence of difficulties in an ancient text does not establish contradiction any more than a word I cannot read in an old letter proves the letter is forged. The overall manuscript tradition, archaeological confirmation, and internal coherence of Scripture are far more significant than the difficulties.

📖 Scripture References

Psalm 19:7, John 10:35, 2 Timothy 3:16, Proverbs 30:5

Have a related question? Submit it and Michael will research the answer from Scripture. Submit a Question →